By Sébastien Brunet, travel advisor at Partez en Voyage | Updated November 2026
☀️ A 5-star hotel with a beautiful beach, several pools, great restaurants and a good price: it sounds perfect!
But is it really the best all-inclusive for you?
That's where things get complicated.
With hundreds of all-inclusive resorts in Mexico, the Dominican Republic, Jamaica, the Caribbean and beyond, it can be hard to find your way. Two hotels can show the same number of stars and similar prices while offering completely different experiences.
A hotel can be wonderful for a family with young children, but much less appealing for a couple looking for peace and quiet. Another may have a gorgeous beach, but be less suited to someone who cares a lot about fine dining.
So, how do you choose the right all-inclusive?
Here are the main criteria to consider before booking.
1. The beach: your number one priority?
For many travellers, the first criterion is simple:
"I want a beautiful beach."
But "beautiful beach" can mean several things.
You may be looking for:
- a long beach for walking;
- calm water for swimming;
- water that's ideal for snorkelling;
- a palm-lined beach;
- plenty of space between lounge chairs;
- ☂️ palapas or natural shade;
- few waves;
- as little sargassum as possible.
The beach should therefore be assessed according to your expectations, and not only based on the hotel's photos.
A magnificent photo taken on a calm day doesn't necessarily tell the whole story.
What about sargassum?
It has become an important concern for many travellers choosing the Caribbean and Mexico.
Some regions are more exposed to sargassum at certain times of the year. The situation can, however, vary considerably from one beach to another and from one year to the next.
If the beach is your absolute priority, the destination and the exact location of the hotel deserve as much attention as the hotel itself.
2. Food: buffet or à la carte restaurants?
Not every traveller has the same expectations when it comes to dining.
For some:
"As long as I have a good buffet and a few options, I'm happy."
For others:
"I want to be able to eat at several à la carte restaurants during my stay."
Before booking, it's therefore useful to check:
- the number of restaurants;
- the types of cuisine offered;
- the quality and variety of the buffet;
- the restaurants included at no extra charge;
- the reservations required;
- the restrictions at certain restaurants;
- vegetarian or special dietary options;
- room service, when available.
And be careful: the number of restaurants isn't necessarily a sign of quality.
A hotel with 10 restaurants isn't automatically better than a hotel with 5.
3. Quiet pool or party atmosphere?
Here's another question that can completely change your choice.
Picture two travellers.
The first wants:
to read a book by the pool
to sip a cocktail in peace
to listen to soft music
to completely unplug
The second wants:
entertainment
music
volleyball
to join in the activities
a festive atmosphere
They could book exactly the same number of stars and yet be much happier in two different hotels.
Some resorts even have several pools with distinct atmospheres: a family pool, a relaxation pool, an adults-only pool or a main pool with entertainment.
You have to look beyond the number of pools.
What matters is the atmosphere you're looking for.
4. Are you travelling with children?
A hotel can be wonderful for adults and much less interesting for a family.
If you're travelling with children, check in particular:
- kids' club;
- activities for teens;
- children's pool;
- water play areas;
- game room;
- slides or water park;
- food choices;
- room layout;
- maximum room capacity.
And above all, your children's ages matter.
A hotel that's exceptional for a family with a 4-year-old won't necessarily be the best choice for a family with two teenagers.
5. Adults only or family hotel?
This is probably one of the most important decisions.
An adults-only hotel can be ideal if you're looking for:
❤️ peace and quiet
fine dining
cocktails
relaxation
spa
a calmer atmosphere
A family hotel may be preferable if you're looking for:
activities for the whole family
family pools
activities for kids and teens
entertainment
kid-friendly dining
Some resorts also offer separate adults and family sections, which can be an interesting compromise.
6. Don't underestimate the room
We often spend a lot of time comparing pools and restaurants, but the room can have a huge impact on your experience.
Ask yourself a few questions:
How much space do you want?
Do you need two beds?
Do you want a suite?
Do you need connecting rooms?
Is an ocean view important?
Do you need a bathtub?
Is a terrace or balcony essential?
Are reduced mobility or stairs a concern?
For some families, a standard room will be perfect.
For others, a family suite with several sleeping areas will make all the difference.
7. Location: how long from the airport to the hotel?
After several hours of travel, nobody necessarily feels like spending another two hours on a bus before reaching the hotel.
Location can therefore be an important criterion.
In particular, look at:
✈️ the distance from the airport;
the approximate transfer time;
the proximity to a town or tourist area;
the region;
the characteristics of the coast.
A slightly more expensive hotel 30 minutes from the airport can sometimes be a better choice than a cheaper hotel requiring a long transfer.
8. Think about your comfort and mobility
This criterion is sometimes forgotten at the time of booking.
Some resorts are huge.
You may have to walk several minutes between:
your room
the pool
the restaurants
the beach
the main facilities.
Some hotels are relatively flat and easy to get around, while others have more slopes, stairs or long distances.
If you're travelling with young children, a stroller, a person with reduced mobility, or simply want to avoid walking too much, this can greatly influence your choice of hotel.
A hotel that's a little less spectacular on paper can sometimes be much more comfortable in reality.
9. Which destination should you choose?
Even before choosing your hotel, you sometimes have to start by choosing the region.
Mexico, the Dominican Republic, Jamaica and the other Caribbean destinations don't offer exactly the same experience.
The differences can involve:
the beaches
the weather
sargassum
✈️ flight length
transfer length
the food
the price
the type of hotels available
the excursions
That's why I rarely recommend starting with:
"What's the best hotel in the South?"
The better question is:
"Which destination and which hotel best match what I'm looking for?"
10. Price: beware of quick comparisons
This is probably one of the most common traps.
You find one hotel at $1,400 per person and another at $1,700.
Which one is better?
It's impossible to know just by looking at the price.
You have to compare what is actually included:
✈️ flights
baggage
transfers
room category
restaurants
drinks
activities
facilities
insurance
booking conditions
Sometimes paying $200 or $300 more gets you a much better experience.
Conversely, a more expensive hotel isn't necessarily the one that will suit you best.
The best value for money isn't always the lowest price.
⭐ And those famous stars?
It's tempting to think:
"This one is 5 stars, so it must be better."
But you need to be careful.
A hotel's rating alone can't tell you:
- the quality of the beach;
- the atmosphere;
- the quality of the food;
- the clientele;
- the distance from the airport;
- the activities;
- the quality of the service;
- the tranquility;
- the overall experience.
Two 5-star hotels can be completely different.
That's why I always prefer to look at the whole experience rather than rely only on a star category.
Traveller reviews: useful, but take a step back
Reading other travellers' comments can be very useful.
But be careful not to base your decision on a single negative review or a single photo posted on social media.
One person may write:
"Hotel too quiet!"
While for you, that would be exactly the advantage.
Another may write:
"Way too much entertainment!"
And another family might see that as a plus.
Reviews should therefore be interpreted according to your own priorities.
So, how do you choose?
Before looking at dozens of hotels, I recommend determining your 3 absolute priorities.
For example:
Couple looking for peace and quiet
- Beautiful beach
- Good dining
- Quiet hotel
Family with young children
- Suitable pools
- Activities for kids
- Easily accessible beach
Family with teenagers
- Activities
- Restaurants and food choices
- Pools and facilities
Couple who simply want to unplug
- Tranquility
- Quality of drinks and restaurants
- Spa and relaxation
Once these priorities are set, the list of possible hotels becomes much easier to narrow down.
That's where a travel advisor can make a difference
With so many options available online, you might think it's enough to compare hotels on a few websites to find the best price.
But the real challenge isn't necessarily to find a hotel.
It's to find the right hotel for you.
An advisor can in particular help you connect:
your expectations → the right destination → the right hotel → the right room → the right plan
And above all, they can ask the questions you may not have thought of.
"Is the beach really your priority?"
"Do you prefer a quiet atmosphere or entertainment?"
"How old are your children?"
"Is it important to limit walking?"
"Do you want lots of à la carte restaurants or would you rather have an excellent buffet?"
"Is this your first trip to this destination?"
These small details are sometimes what makes the difference between an okay trip and a vacation you come home from delighted.
☀️ The best all-inclusive doesn't exist... but the best all-inclusive for you does!
There is no hotel that is objectively the best all-inclusive in the world for everyone.
The best hotel for a family with two young children could be completely different from the one a couple will choose to celebrate their wedding anniversary.
And that's exactly what makes the choice interesting.
Before looking at the price, the stars or the beautiful Instagram photos, start by asking yourself:
"What does my perfect vacation look like?"
Once you know the answer, it becomes much easier to find the hotel that will let you live it.
✈️ Don't know which all-inclusive to choose?
You don't need to spend hours comparing dozens of hotels.
At Partez en Voyage, our advisors can help you determine the destination, resort and plan that truly match your needs, your priorities and your budget.
Dreaming of your next getaway to the South?
Tell us about your ideal vacation. We'll help you find the place that matches it.
Facilities, services, conditions, room categories and inclusions may vary by hotel and package. Information and availability are subject to change.
Subscribe to our newsletter
